• Login
  • Register
en
afsqam ar hy az eu be bn bs bg ca ceb ny zh-CN zh-TWco hr cs da nl en eo et tl fi fr fy gl ka de el gu ht ha haw iw hi hmn hu is ig id ga it ja jw kn kk km ko ku ky lo la lv lt lb mk mg ms ml mt mi mr mn my ne no ps fa pl pt pa ro ru sm gd sr st sn sd si sk sl so es su sw sv tg ta te th tr uk ur uz vi cy xh yi yo zu
Victor Mochere
No Result
View All Result
  • Business
  • Finance
    Top 10 oldest currencies in the world

    Top 10 oldest currencies in the world 2023

    Top 20 largest endowment funds in the world

    Top 20 largest endowment funds in the world 2023

    Criteria banks use to issue business loans

    Criteria banks use to issue business loans

    Top 20 largest bond markets in the world

    Top 20 largest bond markets in the world 2023

    Top 10 cities with the most millionaires in Africa

    Top 10 cities with the most millionaires in Africa 2023

    Top 10 countries with the most millionaires in Africa

    Top 10 countries with the most millionaires in Africa 2023

    How to become a millionaire

    How to become a millionaire

    How to simplify your finances using technology

    How to simplify your finances using technology

    Top 10 best personal finance apps

    Top 10 best personal finance apps 2023

    Guide to altcoins for beginners

    Guide to altcoins for beginners

    Things to consider when choosing a forex broker

    Things to consider when choosing a forex broker

    Top 20 cities with the most millionaires in the world

    Top 20 cities with the most millionaires in the world 2023

    Top 10 richest YouTubers in the world

    Top 10 richest YouTubers in the world 2023

    MrBeast Net Worth

    MrBeast Net Worth 2023

    Top 10 fastest growing economies in Africa

    Top 10 fastest growing economies in Africa 2023

    Top 10 richest real estate billionaires in the world

    Top 10 richest real estate billionaires in the world 2023

    Top 10 richest media billionaires in the world

    Top 10 richest media billionaires in the world 2023

    Sundar Pichai Net Worth

    Sundar Pichai Net Worth 2023

    Top 10 richest retail billionaires in the world

    Top 10 richest retail billionaires in the world 2023

    Rishi Sunak Net Worth

    Rishi Sunak Net Worth 2023

  • Education
    E-learning tools that address learning challenges

    E-learning tools that address learning challenges

    Top 10 best success books

    Top 10 best success books 2023

    Types of insurance to consider for college students

    Types of insurance to consider for college students

    Best self-guided tech courses

    Best self-guided tech courses 2023

    How to check for plagiarism

    How to check for plagiarism

    Benefits of poetry

    Benefits of poetry

    How to introduce education to your child with ADHD

    How to introduce education to your child with ADHD

    Reasons to practice creative writing

    Reasons to practice creative writing

    How to write a good essay for TOEFL

    How to write a good essay for TOEFL

    How learning leads to healthy living

    How learning leads to healthy living

    Top 10 best data science books

    Top 10 best data science books 2023

    Best quotes from PLO Lumumba

    Best quotes from PLO Lumumba

    Best quotes from Amin Maalouf

    Best quotes from Amin Maalouf

    How to write a good thesis

    How to write a good thesis

    Best quotes from Michael Faraday

    Best quotes from Michael Faraday

    Top 20 greatest minds of all time

    Top 20 greatest minds of all time

    Best quotes from Voltaire

    Best quotes from Voltaire

    Best quotes from Chinua Achebe

    Best quotes from Chinua Achebe

    How language skills increase your net worth

    How language skills increase your net worth

    How to get free textbooks

    How to get free textbooks

  • Travel
  • Technology
    How to tell if your phone is SIM locked

    How to tell if your phone is SIM locked

    Things to consider when buying a laptop

    Things to consider when buying a laptop

    How to improve your smartphone battery life

    How to improve your smartphone battery life

    How to create a successful social media strategy

    How to create a successful social media strategy

    How to stay relevant on social media

    How to stay relevant on social media

    How to make money with AI

    How to make money with AI

    How to make money with ChatGPT

    How to make money with ChatGPT

    Common SEO mistakes

    Common SEO mistakes

    How to optimize your WordPress website

    How to optimize your WordPress website

    Top 10 best nursing apps

    Top 10 best nursing apps 2023

    Benefits of digital PR

    Benefits of digital PR

    Facets of digital marketing

    Facets of digital marketing

    Digital marketing strategies for beginners

    Digital marketing strategies for beginners

    How to check supported sleep states on Windows

    How to check supported sleep states on Windows

    How to make your Windows PC boot quicker

    How to make your Windows PC boot quicker

    Guide to Python OCR for beginners

    Guide to Python OCR for beginners

    Different types of internet connections

    Different types of internet connections

    History and evolution of DAOs

    History and evolution of DAOs

    How to secure your online accounts

    How to secure your online accounts

    Future of content writing with AI technology

    Future of content writing with AI technology

  • Living
    Top 20 fastest fighter jets in the world

    Top 20 fastest fighter jets in the world 2023

    Top 20 most densely populated countries in the world

    Top 20 most densely populated countries in the world 2023

    Top 20 most racially diverse countries in the world

    Top 20 most racially diverse countries in the world 2023

    Top 20 most LGBTQ-friendly countries in the world

    Top 20 most LGBTQ-friendly countries in the world 2023

    Top 10 largest uranium reserves in the world

    Top 10 largest uranium reserves in the world 2023

    Top 10 largest uranium mines in the world

    Top 10 largest uranium mines in the world 2023

    How to prevent electronics from blowing up

    How to prevent electronics from blowing up

    How to increase your Fuliza limit

    How to increase your Fuliza limit

    Understanding the eagle mentality

    Understanding the eagle mentality

    Understanding the lion mentality

    Understanding the lion mentality

    How to boost your self-confidence

    How to boost your self-confidence

    Top 10 saddest countries in Africa

    Top 10 saddest countries in Africa 2023

    Top 20 saddest countries in the world

    Top 20 saddest countries in the world 2023

    Top 10 happiest countries in Africa

    Top 10 happiest countries in Africa 2023

    Top 20 happiest countries in the world

    Top 20 happiest countries in the world 2023

    Things to consider when buying an equestrian estate

    Things to consider when buying an equestrian estate

    Things to consider when choosing a dog groomer

    Things to consider when choosing a dog groomer

    Top 10 greatest engineers of all time

    Top 10 greatest engineers of all time

    Types of women that can ruin your marriage

    Types of women that can ruin your marriage

    7 C's of success

    7 C’s of success

  • Entertainment
    Top 20 best-selling video games of all time

    Top 20 best-selling video games of all time

    Top 20 most complex movies of all time

    Top 20 most complex movies of all time

    Best quotes from Whitney Houston

    Best quotes from Whitney Houston

    Top 10 most rewatchable movies

    Top 10 most rewatchable movies 2023

    Best quotes from Denzel Washington

    Best quotes from Denzel Washington

    Snack ideas for an online gaming night

    Snack ideas for an online gaming night

    Best quotes from Frank Sinatra

    Best quotes from Frank Sinatra

    Roku vs Amazon Fire Stick: Which is better?

    Roku vs Amazon Fire Stick: Which is better?

    Top 20 highest paid entertainers in the world

    Top 20 highest paid entertainers in the world 2023

    Best quotes from Shonda Rhimes

    Best quotes from Shonda Rhimes

    Best poker tips for beginners

    Best poker tips for beginners

    Top 10 best budget wireless headphones

    Top 10 best budget wireless headphones 2023

    Best quotes from Betty White

    Best quotes from Betty White

    History of the slot machine

    History of the slot machine

    The art of gambling

    The art of gambling

    Free internet TV channels you can watch online

    Free internet TV channels you can watch online

    Top 10 most Grammy Awards nominees of all time

    Top 10 most Grammy Awards nominees of all time

    Top 10 most Grammy Awards winners of all time

    Top 10 most Grammy Awards winners of all time

    Why casino whales prefer to play online baccarat

    Why casino whales prefer to play online baccarat

    Benefits of using an online video editor for your vlog

    Benefits of using an online video editor for your vlog

  • Governance
    Members of Parliament in Kenya

    Members of Parliament in Kenya 2023

    Principal Secretaries in Kenya

    Principal Secretaries in Kenya 2023

    Cabinet Secretaries in Kenya

    Cabinet Secretaries in Kenya 2023

    Top 10 ruthless African warlords of all time

    Top 10 ruthless African warlords of all time

    Best quotes from Kwame Nkrumah

    Best quotes from Kwame Nkrumah

    What you need to know about IEBC forms

    What you need to know about IEBC forms

    Top 20 largest empires of all time

    Top 20 largest empires of all time

    Diplomatic number plates in Kenya

    Diplomatic number plates in Kenya

    Best quotes from Marcus Aurelius

    Best quotes from Marcus Aurelius

    Best quotes from Vladimir Lenin

    Best quotes from Vladimir Lenin

    Best quotes from John Magufuli

    Best quotes from John Magufuli

    Best quotes from Volodymyr Zelenskyy

    Best quotes from Volodymyr Zelenskyy

    Best quotes from Vladimir Putin

    Best quotes from Vladimir Putin

    Best quotes from Angela Merkel

    Best quotes from Angela Merkel

    Top 20 countries with the most debt in the world

    Top 20 countries with the most debt in the world 2023

    Top 10 least indebted countries in Africa

    Top 10 least indebted countries in Africa 2023

    Top 10 most indebted countries in Africa

    Top 10 most indebted countries in Africa 2023

    Top 20 least indebted countries in the world

    Top 20 least indebted countries in the world 2023

    Top 20 most indebted countries in the world

    Top 20 most indebted countries in the world 2023

    Monarchs of Britain

    Monarchs of Britain

  • Sports
    Best quotes from Pelé

    Best quotes from Pelé

    How to bet on the NFL

    How to bet on the NFL

    How to bet on the Breeders' Cup

    How to bet on the Breeders’ Cup

    Types of swimming styles and strokes

    Types of swimming styles and strokes

    Benefits of swimming

    Benefits of swimming

    Safety rules every swimmer should follow

    Safety rules every swimmer should follow

    Must-have equipment for softball coaches

    Must-have equipment for softball coaches

    How to take advantage of changing odds

    How to take advantage of changing odds

    Guide to baseball betting

    Guide to baseball betting

    Top 10 most watched sporting events of all time

    Top 10 most watched sporting events of all time

    Top 10 highest paid NFL players

    Top 10 highest paid NFL players 2023

    Top 10 richest sports leagues in the world

    Top 10 richest sports leagues in the world 2023

    Top 10 most popular sports in the world

    Top 10 most popular sports in the world 2023

    Top 10 highest paid NHL players in the world

    Top 10 highest paid NHL players in the world 2023

    Top 10 football players with the most free kick goals

    Top 10 football players with the most free kick goals 2023

    Slam Dunk: How to become an NBA betting pro

    Slam Dunk: How to become an NBA betting pro

    History of badminton in the Olympic Games

    History of badminton in the Olympic Games

    Top 10 most lucrative football shirt sponsorships

    Top 10 most lucrative football shirt sponsorships 2023

    Top 10 countries with the least Olympic medals in Africa

    Top 10 countries with the least Olympic medals in Africa 2023

    Top 20 countries with the least Olympic medals in the world

    Top 20 countries with the least Olympic medals in the world 2023

en
afsqam ar hy az eu be bn bs bg ca ceb ny zh-CN zh-TWco hr cs da nl en eo et tl fi fr fy gl ka de el gu ht ha haw iw hi hmn hu is ig id ga it ja jw kn kk km ko ku ky lo la lv lt lb mk mg ms ml mt mi mr mn my ne no ps fa pl pt pa ro ru sm gd sr st sn sd si sk sl so es su sw sv tg ta te th tr uk ur uz vi cy xh yi yo zu
Victor Mochere
No Result
View All Result
en
afsqam ar hy az eu be bn bs bg ca ceb ny zh-CN zh-TWco hr cs da nl en eo et tl fi fr fy gl ka de el gu ht ha haw iw hi hmn hu is ig id ga it ja jw kn kk km ko ku ky lo la lv lt lb mk mg ms ml mt mi mr mn my ne no ps fa pl pt pa ro ru sm gd sr st sn sd si sk sl so es su sw sv tg ta te th tr uk ur uz vi cy xh yi yo zu
Victor Mochere
No Result
View All Result
Home Living

Review of the Muruatetu case

Victor Mochere by Victor Mochere
April 27, 2021
in Living
Reading Time: 4 mins read
A A
0
Review of the Muruatetu case
On 14 December, 2017 the Supreme Court of Kenya, Francis Karioko Muruatetu & another v Republic [2017] eKLR, delivered a judgment that had the effect of outlawing the mandatory nature of the death sentence. In the said petition, the petitioners Francis Karioko Muruatetu and Wilson Thirimbu Mwangi, were death row convicts who had been in jail for the last 14 years. They filed the petition before the Supreme Court asking the court to scrap the mandatory death penalty from the Kenyan law. The duo were convicted for the murder of businessman Lawrence Githinji Magondu.

The Supreme Court findings

In determining the petition, the Supreme Court made the following findings:
  1. Declared the mandatory nature of the death sentence as provided for under Section 204 of the Penal Code unconstitutional
  2. Remitted to the High Court the case for rehearing on sentence only, in conformity with the judgment
  3. Directed the Attorney General, the Director of Public Prosecutions and other relevant agencies to prepare a detailed professional review in the context of the Judgment and order, with a view to setting up a framework to deal with sentence re-hearing of cases similar to that of the petitioners
  4. Directed that any necessary amendments, formulations and enactment of statute law, be done to give effect to the judgment and on the parameters of what ought to constitute life imprisonment

The Supreme Court’s judgment and reasoning

The Supreme Court of Kenya in the Muruatetu case confirmed that the death penalty per se is not unconstitutional, however noted that the United Nations Commission on Human Rights has recommended the abolition of the death sentence as a mandatory sentence. With respect therefore to the mandatory nature of the death penalty in section 204 of the Penal Code, the Court held that the imposition of a sentence of death without considering mitigating circumstances violates the right to a fair trial guaranteed in Article 50(2) of the COK 2010, which right may not be limited pursuant to Article 25.

Specifically, the Court stated that; “Section 204 of the Penal Code deprives the Court of the use of judicial discretion in a matter of life and death. Such law can only be regarded as harsh, unjust and unfair. The mandatory nature deprives the Courts of their legitimate jurisdiction to exercise discretion not to impose the death sentence in appropriate cases. Where a court listens to mitigating circumstances but has, nonetheless, to impose a set sentence, the sentence imposed fails to conform to the tenets of fair trial that accrue to accused persons under Articles 25 of the Constitution which is an a absolute right.’’

Accordingly, the Court held that due process requires a sentencing court to consider whether the death sentence is appropriate in light of the circumstances of the offence and the offender. Noting that Kenya has recently issued the guidelines on sentencing that confirms the mandatory nature of the death penalty, the Court also held that the relevant sections of the policy are no longer applicable, and instead set out new guidelines with respect to mitigating factors that a sentencing court must take into consideration in determining whether to impose a death sentence or some term of imprisonment upon conviction for murder.

Recommended criteria in sentencing

Reiterating that judicial discretion is key to achieve a fair trial, the Court clarified that the following criteria are advisory and intended to promote transparency and consistency in sentencing:

  • Age of the offender
  • Being a first offender
  • Whether the offender pleaded guilty
  • Character and record of the offender
  • Commission of the offence in response to gender-based violence
  • Remorsefulness of the offender
  • The possibility of reform and social re-adaptation of the offender
  • Any other factor that the Court considers relevant

Conclusion

In summary, the decision by the Supreme Court was to the effect that death sentence is still lawful but not mandatory and that new sentencing procedures will now have to be adopted in serious criminal proceedings in Kenya. This means that judges will be able to exercise discretion over whether the death penalty should be imposed, taking into account all mitigating factors, such as the mental health of the offender, the circumstances of their offence and good character evidence, to ensure that the sentence imposed is proportionate.

In the recent past, some courts have applied the Muruatetu Case mutatis mutandi in offences attracting life imprisonment. Section 26 of the Penal Code sets parameters for a sentence of imprisonment, and specifically provides that in the absence of a mandatory sentence, a person liable to life imprisonment may be sentenced to any shorter term. The Penal Code does not however specify or clarify the meaning of ‘life’ in respect of life imprisonment.

Until the Supreme Court’s decision in Muruatetu, life imprisonment in Kenya has been for an indeterminate period, i.e. the natural life of the convicted person. There are twenty-nine (29) offences in the Penal Code for which a convicted person is liable to imprisonment for life. There are a further eight offences in the Sexual Offences Act that provide for a maximum, and in some cases mandatory, sentence of imprisonment for life. Numerous other statutes also contain offences for which a convicted person is or may be liable to imprisonment for life.

Tags: Law
Previous Post

Importance of fascia and soffit

Next Post

Guide on fashion trend forecasting

Victor Mochere

Victor Mochere

Victor Mochere is a blogger, social media influencer, and netpreneur creating and marketing digital content.

Next Post
Guide on fashion trend forecasting

Guide on fashion trend forecasting

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Trending Posts

  • Top 20 fastest goals in football history

    Top 20 fastest goals in football history 2023

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • Top 10 worst universities in Kenya 2023

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • Top 10 most educated presidents in Africa 2023

    1 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • Postbank Kenya branch codes 2023

    1 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • Top 10 most expensive presidential cars in Africa 2023

    27 shares
    Share 27 Tweet 0

Find us on

Newspaper Flipboard

Download our app

Google-play Microsoft Amazon Shopping-bag

Newsletter

Follow us

Facebook-f Twitter Instagram Pinterest Linkedin Youtube Tiktok Snapchat-ghost Telegram Rss
Victor Mochere

Victor Mochere is one of the biggest informational blogs on the web. We publish well curated up-to-date facts and important updates from around the world.

Recent posts

  • Top 20 fastest fighter jets in the world 2023
  • Top 20 most densely populated countries in the world 2023
  • Top 20 most racially diverse countries in the world 2023
  • Top 20 most LGBTQ-friendly countries in the world 2023
  • Top 10 cheapest banks in Kenya 2023

Sections

  • Business
  • Education
  • Entertainment
  • Finance
  • Flacked
  • Governance
  • Living
  • Sports
  • Technology
  • Travel

Download our app

Google-play Microsoft Amazon Shopping-bag

Find us on

Newspaper Flipboard
  • Advertise
  • Disclaimer
  • Cookies
  • Privacy Policy
  • Copyright
  • DMCA
  • Write For Us
  • Send us a topic
  • Contact

© 2023 Victor Mochere. All rights are reserved.

en
afsqam ar hy az eu be bn bs bg ca ceb ny zh-CN zh-TWco hr cs da nl en eo et tl fi fr fy gl ka de el gu ht ha haw iw hi hmn hu is ig id ga it ja jw kn kk km ko ku ky lo la lv lt lb mk mg ms ml mt mi mr mn my ne no ps fa pl pt pa ro ru sm gd sr st sn sd si sk sl so es su sw sv tg ta te th tr uk ur uz vi cy xh yi yo zu
  • Login
  • Sign Up
No Result
View All Result
  • Sections
    • Finance
    • Education
    • Technology
    • Living
    • Entertainment
    • Governance
    • Sports
  • About
  • Victor Mochere
  • Donate
  • Sitemap
  • Crossword
  • Social Media Policy
  • Corrections Policy
  • Comment Policy

© 2023 Victor Mochere. All rights are reserved.

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password? Sign Up

Create New Account!

Fill the forms below to register

All fields are required. Log In

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In